This review will contain spoilers throughout
I'll be upfront about this I will compare this to the 1981 version. I adore the 1981 film so I may not have started out in an unbiased state. I know the 1981 film isn't great but it's a childhood fave and has all the charm I need.
The cast list for this film is pretty good. Plenty of great actors. Most of the cast did a pretty good job. It's just that they didn't have a great script to work with. The exception in the cast was no surprise to me. The charisma vacuum that is Sam Worthington. He really should stick to playing someone the director doesn't want me to empathise with. I cannot understand why he keeps getting leading roles. Perseus has a number 2 cut. Everyone else has long hair, why? Perseus speaks in an Aussie accent? That's just plain wrong. Sam would be wise not to share a screen with an actor of Postlethwaite's calibre again
I know that when they remake a film/film a book/etc they will change the story somewhat. This I rarely like but if it makes sense fair enough, needs must. The original film didn't stick to the original legends. What they failed in this film was to portray the Gods and their everyday effect on the human race. We saw them destruct, we didn't see them add anything. They were one note performances, if that. They brought Danny Huston in to play Poseidon, blink and you miss him. Dr Bashir (as Mr Siddig will forever be known) didn't get more than one line. Without an understanding of the Gods and their overseeing/meddling with the human race this story is empty.
You bring Ralph Fiennes in? Great, he's got some pretty fine acting chops. So he'll play Hades, the baddy. He's been banished from Olympus. He appears and disappears in a puff of smoke. Has a human do his dirty work. Speaks in a whisper, admit it his second name is Voldemort. For heaven's sake it was embarrassing.
The Clash of the Titans, Titans seemingly being Lord of the Rings, Harry Potter and Alien. Now I know films in the fantasy genre often use similar apects. If a film has carved it's place you may not even notice it, if it feels in place it doesn't bother you. Here it grated on me to the point of distraction. During their journey I was looking for a Hobbit. When they tamed a monster scorpion and saddled it I wanted to scream Oliphant. Nothing rang true.
I think the writer or director was trying to make a point somewhere along the line. I'm not sure what that point was though. It just felt like I was being hammered with something. When Calibas gasped to Perseus 'don't become like them' as he was slain it was sooooooooo out of place. Calibas supposedly hated Perseus. Why would he care if he took his place on Olympus. Did the writer want to tell me something with Perseus' hatred of the Gods? They changed the story so that Hades killed his mother.
Why did we need a love interest other than Andromeda? Io would have made a good addition had she been watching over Perseus rather than getting him into the sack. Was the lone, very human Perseus at the end supposed to tell me something?
Now my final point is the cardinal sin in this remake. One of the best parts of the original was Athena's mechanical owl Bubo. Yes I can hear you all screaming that it was a crappy R2 copy but I love it. When Perseus picked it up (what looked like the original prop) I was happy, for a split-second. When he was told to leave it I was gutted but assumed he had it in his back pack. He didn't. How dare the writers dis' a part of the original whilst they were busy relieving themselves all over it's memory.
I had my childhood raped and was forced to sit and watch it on the big screen. It's only bonus was that it was relatively short in today's terms.
1 out of 5 pawprints.
3 comments:
Jinkies! (sigh) I still have to see it, though. I'll admit, hesitantly, that the absence of Bubo would be a plus in my book, but it sounds like I shall have to premedicate for this one. Thanks for the warning.
Good post Mary, summed up my feelings and that was without me having seen the original. The biggest issue for me was lack of clarity as to who the hell anybody actually was.
Well, I haven't seen the original since I was a kid so can't remember a great deal about it. I watched the 2010 version last night and I thought it was okay - as modern, CGI loaded, monster-mash, plot-lite abominations go.
Sam Worthington has the personality of an envelope, Liam Neeson phoned in his 'performance' and Ralph Fiennes was wasted. Christ Almighty he was better in The Avengers... The only decent performances came from Postlethwaite, Mads Mikkelson and Gemma Arterton - and all three of those got far less screen time than they should.
To be honest though, this wasn't about the people (which is lucky, as I couldn't give a shit about any of them, particularly Andromeda), it was about the monsters and they were okay. Ish. Nothing new really, seen it all before. Far too many times.
It was a far more entertaining way to waste an evening than sitting through Avatar (which I will NOT watch again). Worthington must be getting used to flying imaginary creatures by now. He'll probably have a panic attack if they ask him to do anything for real...
Oh yes, and the 3D was dreadful.
Post a Comment